This was based on a tutortial by at CO+K by Lady Llanalla that produced a very realistic looking lemon slice.
This is only my second attempt at making felt food and I don't know if it was because I used fleece instead of felt for the yellow parts, if the rind band was too wide or if it because I partly machine sew and partly hand stitched it, but it didn't turn out to look like a lemon slice.
Guesses when I asked if they knew what it was were: A moon pie, an inside out moon pie, a cookie, a mini-cake, a piece of dough and "something edible -is it? Can I have it?". Only my son ventured to guess - is that the lemon slice that you showed me you were going to make?
The upside is it is my for great-niece for Christmas and she will not be quite 2 then and it can be whatever she wants it to be. Either that or she is going to think all lemon slices should be a least a inch or more thick.